Skip to content

A Phased Approach to Trauma Therapy

Summary of “Trauma Competency: An Active Ingredients Approach to Treating Posttraumatic Stress Disorder” by Gentry, Baranowsky, and Rhoton (2017)

In this article, Gentry and colleagues propose that most evidence-based treatments for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) share four “active ingredients” or core elements that account for their effectiveness. By focusing on these common factors, counselors can improve client outcomes regardless of the specific therapeutic model used. The four ingredients they identify are:

  1. Cognitive Restructuring and Psychoeducation
  2. Helping clients understand how trauma affects the brain, body, and behavior.
  3. Normalizing symptoms to reduce shame, guilt, and self-blame.
  4. Teaching about the biology of threat response and reframing maladaptive thoughts.
  5. Therapeutic Relationship
  6. Emphasizing the quality of the counselor–client connection as essential for healing.
  7. Using Feedback-Informed Treatment (FIT) to enhance rapport, tailor therapy, and improve outcomes.
  8. Demonstrating empathy, warmth, genuineness, and the capacity for self-regulation as key counselor traits.
  9. Self-Regulation and Relaxation
  10. Training clients in stress-management techniques (e.g., breathing, mindfulness, progressive muscle relaxation) to downregulate overactive autonomic responses.
  11. Helping clients build skills to calm physiological arousal, facilitating effective processing of traumatic memories.
  12. Exposure or Narrative Work
  13. Safely confronting or recounting traumatic experiences to desensitize and integrate fragmented memories.
  14. Combining exposure with learned relaxation skills (“reciprocal inhibition”) to help reduce trauma-related anxiety.
  15. Constructing and expanding the trauma narrative, often in phases, so that traumatic memories become less overwhelming.

A Phased Approach to Trauma Therapy

Building on established phase-based models (e.g., Judith Herman’s three-phase approach), the authors outline a four-stage clinical framework that incorporates these active ingredients:

  1. Relationship Building
  2. Orient clients to treatment expectations and goals.
  3. Introduce Feedback-Informed Treatment measures and a predictable session structure.
  4. Establish trust, model self-regulation, and maintain a sense of safety.
  5. Psychoeducation and Self-Regulation
  6. Teach basic neuroscience of trauma and the body’s threat-response system.
  7. Introduce and practice relaxation strategies to help clients gain mastery over physiological arousal.
  8. Normalize posttraumatic reactions while reframing symptoms as adaptive responses to overwhelming events.
  9. Recovery and Resolution
  10. Engage in exposure-based interventions (e.g., prolonged exposure, EMDR, cognitive processing therapy).
  11. Integrate clients’ trauma narratives, focusing on sensory, emotional, and cognitive components of traumatic memories.
  12. Use ongoing self-regulation techniques to prevent emotional overwhelm.
  13. Work through grief and loss associated with trauma.
  14. Posttraumatic Resiliency Building
  15. Consolidate learning and foster posttraumatic growth.
  16. Address changes in self-perception, relationships, and life philosophy.
  17. Identify new strengths and adaptive coping that have emerged through recovery.

Key Takeaways

  • No Single “Best” Method: Meta-analyses show that many evidence-based treatments have similar effectiveness; the difference lies in consistently applying the core common factors.
  • Quality of the Therapeutic Relationship: Actively eliciting client feedback (FIT) and counselor self-regulation are crucial for building and maintaining an alliance.
  • Self-Regulation First: Teaching clients to manage autonomic arousal is foundational and prepares them to process traumatic memories safely.
  • Exposure Matters: A central therapeutic mechanism is facing traumatic memories, paired with relaxation strategies, to reduce their power.
  • Competency, Not Model Loyalty: The authors suggest that trauma counselors achieve “trauma competency” by integrating these four core tasks (psychoeducation, relationship, self-regulation, and exposure) within any chosen evidence-based protocol.

This “active ingredients” approach provides a flexible framework that guides counselors through essential tasks—relationship building, educating, regulating, exposure, and growth—thereby promoting more consistent, effective treatment for clients suffering from PTSD.